The Storm Ledger11 markets · 3 states · as of 17 Nov 2026

The model works. The strategy does not.

A hidden Markov model sorts each session into three volatility states, refit out of sample on every market independently. It succeeds at what it was built for and fails at what it was hoped to do.

Across 11 markets and 2,609 out-of-sample sessions, volatility rises monotonically through the three states on 10 of 11. Return does not. It carries no ordering at all on 6 of 11, and where an ordering does appear it points both ways: ascending on 2, backwards on 3. The states rank risk. They do not rank return, and a strategy that trades them as though they did loses to a static sixty-forty.

Eleven markets, three years, one plate

Each row is one market: its price path above, its regime rail below. Crisis is the only state that washes the whole row, so simultaneity reads as a column instead of as eleven separate rails.

NIFTY 50
^NSEI
Bank NIFTY
^NSEBANK
NIFTY IT
^CNXIT
S&P 500
SPY
Nasdaq 100
QQQ
US 20y+ Treasury
TLT
Gold
GC=F
Silver
SI=F
WTI crude
CL=F †
Copper
HG=F
Natural gas
NG=F †
18 Nov 202320242025202617 Nov 2026

BullBearCrisisEleven models were fitted independently, one per market, with no shared state variable. The alignment describes one event. It is not a contagion claim, and nothing here estimates a link between markets.

What the plate shows

Between 10 Apr 2025 and 7 May 2025, 9 of 11 markets sat in Crisis at once, and held there for 28 days. Eleven models that share no state variable agreed on one month.

Then look again at the price paths inside that band. Several of them are rising. That is the finding: these states rank violence, not direction, and de-risking into the darkest one sells the rebound along with the crash.

The same eleven markets, twice

Both plates are built identically and differ in exactly one variable. Left, annualised volatility by state. Right, annualised return by state. Read down each column and the argument makes itself.

ANNUALISED VOLATILITY · RISES ON 10/11

NIFTY 50
Bank NIFTY
NIFTY IT
S&P 500
Nasdaq 100
US 20y+ Treasury
Gold
Silver
WTI crude
Copper
Natural gas

ANNUALISED RETURN · NO ORDERING ON 6/11

NIFTY 50
Bank NIFTY
NIFTY IT
S&P 500
Nasdaq 100
US 20y+ Treasury
Gold
Silver
WTI crude
Copper
Natural gas

Each line runs Bull to Bear to Crisis, left to right; dots carry the state colour. Markets with fewer than 3 crisis episodes are excluded from the return verdict, because an ordering read off two episodes is not an ordering. Backwards on ^NSEI, SPY, QQQ. Ascending on ^CNXIT, NG=F.

Where each market stands today

State, how long it has held, and the position size implied by holding a constant 10% risk budget. That last figure is arithmetic on a measured volatility, not a backtested position.

INDIA

NIFTY 50 ^NSEI
Bear
33 sessions · since 29 Sept 2026
15.3% vol → 65%
Bank NIFTY ^NSEBANK
Bull
2 sessions · since 16 Nov 2026
14.8% vol → 68%
NIFTY IT ^CNXIT
Bear
1 sessions · since 17 Nov 2026
19.4% vol → 52%

GLOBAL

S&P 500 SPY
Bear
4 sessions · since 12 Nov 2026
15.1% vol → 66%
Nasdaq 100 QQQ
Crisis
13 sessions · since 30 Oct 2026
30.9% vol → 32%
US 20y+ Treasury TLT
Bull
89 sessions · since 15 Jul 2026
11.6% vol → 86%

COMMODITIES

Gold GC=F
Crisis
406 sessions · since 9 Apr 2025
20.4% vol → 49%
Silver SI=F
Crisis
25 sessions · since 14 Oct 2026
44.8% vol → 22%
WTI crude CL=F
Bear
44 sessions · since 17 Sept 2026
39.1% vol → 26%
Copper HG=F
Bull
23 sessions · since 16 Oct 2026
21.9% vol → 46%
Natural gas NG=F
Bull
33 sessions · since 2 Oct 2026
44.0% vol → 23%

3 of 11 markets are in Crisis as of 17 Nov 2026: Nasdaq 100, Gold, Silver. Position size is target volatility divided by the realized volatility measured in that regime, capped at 1.0. Arithmetic on a measured quantity, shown so a risk budget can be read off the regime. It is not a backtested strategy, not a traded position, and not advice., capped at one; the cap is drawn rather than hidden.